Bright Eyes. Ultimately it was the voice. Sure, the comparisons to Dylan were a bit annoying, but yeah. The voice just didn't do it for me. Although I did enjoy At the Bottom of Everything from 2005's I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning.
Today, like, right now, I'm trying and failing to like The Mountain Goats. I'm listening to All Eternals Deck as I write this, and, in fact, I'm pretty sure this album inspired me to put together this artist fight. Again with the voice. I just can't take it.
Have at it. Who wins in a fist fight?